We derive several unambiguous comparative statics results with the additive background risk with the use of the concept of the meanvariance vulnerability. In this study, a timevariant variance and timevariant expected market demand model are introduced to investigate the order strategies that. Meanvariance analysis quantifies the notions of risk and expected return by applying concepts from statistics. By looking at the expected return and variance of an asset, investors attempt. Generally speaking, utility maximization is mainly used in theoretical study, while mean variance tradeo. Chen and federgruen 32 study a mv tradeoff analysis on several basic inventory models, and found that the optimal order quantity is less than or equal to the newsboy point if the decision maker is riskaverse. Nonetheless, some models or methods have been developed in the recent past for determining the optimum level of inventories to be maintained in the enterprise.
They model a quadratic utility function for inventory manager and construct an efficient frontier for the noninferior solution points. Modern portfolio theory mpt, or meanvariance analysis, is a mathematical framework for assembling a portfolio of assets such that the expected return is maximized for a given level of risk. Meanvariance optimization and the capm these lecture notes provide an introduction to meanvariance analysis and the capital asset pricing model capm. The sum of all variances gives a picture of the overall overperformance or underperformance for a particular reporting period fiscal year fy a fiscal year fy is a 12 month or 52 week period of time used by governments and businesses. This paper examines the effects of an additive background risk on the optimal order quantity of a riskaverse newsvendor with meanvariance utility. As you will see, the name is appropriate because inferences about means are made by analyzing variance. An empirical research on marketing strategies of different. Chen and federgruen 14 revisit a number of basic inventory models using the meanvariance approach. A meanvariance analysis is the process of weighing risk variance against expected return. Meansd after that, chen and federgruen 2000 conduct a meanvariance analysis of various im portant basic inventory models which include the single period newsvendor problem as well as the multiperiod r, nq base stock inventory problem. Federgruen, meanvariance analysis of basic inventory. Chen and federgruen 2000 revisit a number of basic inventory models using the mean variance approach. Assumption 2 q and s follow respectively distributions with p. Meanvariance tradeoffs in supply contracts1 1 introduction mit.
They exhibit how a systematic mean variance tradeo analysis can be carried out e ciently and how the resulting strategies di er from those obtained in the standard analyses. Parallel works to incorporate various other challenges. Second, we study the optimal decisions of channel members considering the risk factor in three situations. Meanvariance analysis and the diversification of risk. Meanvariance analysis in portfolio choice and capital. Meanvariance analysis modern portfolio theory identifies two aspects of the investment problem. Second, an investor will want to minimize the risk of the portfolio. Meanvariance analvsis and the diversification of risk leigh j. We construct analytical models and reveal the problems structural properties. Basic statistical tools, degree of dispersion, measures of central tendency, parametric tests and nonparametric tests, variables, variance introduction statistics is a branch of science that deals with the collection, organisation, analysis of data and drawing of inferences from the samples to the whole population. Design flexible supply chain contracts with options. Meanvariance analysis of basic inventory models request pdf. It may seem odd that the technique is called analysis of variance rather than analysis of means. Most of the research in this stream considers singleperiod inventory models.
The basic idea is that everyone in the population has the same score the grand mean that is changed by the effects of an independent variable a plus just random. Meanvariance analysis of the newsvendor model with stockout cost. They exhibit how a systematic mean variance tradeoff analysis can be carried out efficiently. Supply chain risk analysis with meanvariance models. Chen and federgruen 2000 revisita number of basic inventory models using the meanvariance approach. Pdf supply chain risk analysis with meanvariance models. Review of basic statistics and the mean model for forecasting. A pricesetting newsvendor problem under meanvariance. Supply chain coordination with a riskaverse retailer and.
Chinese journal of management science,151,2007,1620. Basic analysis of variance and the general linear model psy 420 andrew ainsworth. Markowitz in the 1950s developed meanvariance analysis, the theory of combining risky assets so as to minimize the variance of return i. They show that without stockout cost the variance of the profit is a. A note on meanvariance analysis of the newsvendor model core. Lau, the newsboy problem under alternative optimization objectives. Meanrisk analysis of radio frequency identification. The baumoltobin and the tobin meanvariance models of the demand for money 1william j. We derive several unambiguous comparative statics results with the additive background risk with the use of the concept of the mean variance vulnerability. Supply chain coordination with a riskaverse retailer and a. Risk management in operations spring 2006 subject to minor revisions. Modern portfolio theory mpt, or mean variance analysis, is a mathematical framework for assembling a portfolio of assets such that the expected return is maximized for a given level of risk.
Keywords newsvendor model, meanvariance approach, risk hedging. If we are interested in group mean differences, why are we looking at variance. Nowadays, there is no doubt that the mean variance mv theory is a wellproven approach for. The measure of risk by variance would place equal weight. May 16, 20 pioneered by nobel laureate harry markowitz in the 1950s, the mean variance mv formulation is a fundamental theory for risk management in finance. Harry markowitz has applied computer and mathematical techniques to various practical decision making areas. Chen and federgruen 2000 revisit a number of basic inventory models using the meanvariance approach. Mean variance optimization and the capm these lecture notes provide an introduction to mean variance analysis and the capital asset pricing model capm. We study the riskaverse newsvendor model with a mean variance objective function. We begin with the mean variance analysis of markowitz 1952 when there is no riskfree asset and then move on to the case where there is a riskfree asset available. Evaluation of risky prospects based on the expected value and variance of possible outcomes. We show that stockout cost has a significant impact on the newsvendors optimal ordering decisions.
In view of the growing importance of mv approach in supply chain management. The locus of optimal meanvariance combinations is called the efficient. First, an investor will want to maximize the expected rate of return on the portfolio. Chen and federgruen 7 presented this meanvariance analysis for different planning problems, namely, the newsvendor problem, the base stock problem and the r, nq model. Investment theory prior to markowitz considered the maximization of p but without. Fiscal year fy a fiscal year fy is a 12 month or 52 week period of time used by governments and businesses. Recently, mv analysis method has been applied in many sides of supply chain management. Meanvariance analysis of stochastic inventory models. A note on meanvariance analysis of the newsvendor model. A decision support system for meanvariance analysis in multi. Variance analysis learn how to calculate and analyze variances. Risk analysis using the meanvariance theory, the last topic, is first incorporated into inventory control problem especially newsvendor problem that is the optimal product order quantity for a.
Our main contribution in this paper is in the field of meanvariance analysis in inventory control. Chen and others published meanvariance analysis of basic inventory models find, read and cite all the research you need. Meanvariance models for portfolio selection with fuzzy random returns 20 september 2008 journal of applied mathematics and computing, vol. This is in a sharp contrast with the risk neutral formulation of the inventory model where all optimal policies are time consistent. Marketingoperations analysis for the provision of incentives for a multitask salesforce. In an intensely competitive market, individual merchants are able to get more sales opportunities if they display their products earlier. We illustrate this finding analytically for the case where the demand follows the. The baumoltobin and the tobin meanvariance models of the. Jan 20, 2015 this paper examines the effects of an additive background risk on the optimal order quantity of a riskaverse newsvendor with mean variance utility. Meanvariance newsvendor model with a background risk.
Each author name for a columbia business school faculty member is linked to a faculty research page, which lists additional publications by that faculty member. Using mv analysis methods in a singleechelon supply chain, chen and federgruen examine various basic inventory models. The chapter presents a markowitz meanvariance model written in matlab, with an alternative model presented in the appendix of the text written in gams. The contracts used in our model are portfolios of simple. Mean variance analysis of stochastic inventory models.
Meanvariance analysis for the newsvendor problem ieee xplore. Working paper, graduate school of business, columbia university, new york, ny. It is a formalization and extension of diversification in investing, the idea that owning different kinds of financial assets is less risky than owning. We begin with the meanvariance analysis of markowitz 1952 when there is no riskfree asset and then move on to the case where there is a riskfree asset available. The baumoltobin and the tobin meanvariance models of. Variance analysis is an important part of an organizations information system. Variance analysis learn how to calculate and analyze.
Mean variance analysis of the newsvendormodel with. A pricesetting newsvendor problem under meanvariance criteria. As a fundamental problem in stochastic inventory control. Variance analysis can be summarized as an analysis of the difference between planned and actual numbers.
They exhibit how a systematic meanvariance tradeo analysis can be carried out e ciently and how the resulting strategies di er from those obtained in the standard analyses. Glm performs analysis of variance, regression, analysis of covariance, repeated measures analysis, and multivariate analysis of variance. An inventory theoretic approach, quarterly journal of economics 66 1952. Over the past decades, there is a growing popularity of applying this ground breaking theory in analyzing stochastic supply chain management problems. Chen and federgruen 14 revisit a number of basic inventory models using the mean variance approach. Mean variance analysis of the newsvendormodel with stockout. The models use measures of mean return and variance to either maximize return subject to a variance penalty, or minimize variance subject to a desired return. A simplified model for portfolio analysis management science. Moreover, some results obtained in the previous literature may no longer be valid. We illustrate this finding analytically for the case where the demand. If stockout cost is considered in the newsvendor model, the properties of the variance function and the meanvariance tradeoff may be very different from those of the model without stockout cost. A note on meanvariance analysis of the newsvendor model with.
The basic idea in the baumoltobin analysis is that there is an opportunity cost of hold. This opportunity cost is the bond interest rate i times average cash balances held during the period, which, from the discussion in the chapter, we know is. Holiday merchandise has unique demand characteristics, unofficial start data, and a limited life cycle. Meanvariance analysis of basic inventory models, working paper, columbia business school, new york, usa. In particular, they determine comparativestatic effects of changes in the various price and cost parameters in the risk aversion setting. Nowadays, there is no doubt that the meanvariance mv theory is a wellproven approach for conducting risk analysis in stochastic supply chain operational models. In our mv model for the newsvendor model, the basic cash flow 4 has. The case of the newsboy problem optimality conditions.
Our analysis of the tradeoff between profit mean and variance highlight two special port. Variance analysis for the newsvendor problem ieee xplore. It is a formalization and extension of diversification in investing, the idea that owning different kinds of financial assets is less risky than owning only one type. A decision support system for meanvariance analysis in. Basic analysis of variance and the general linear model. Nowadays, there is no doubt that the meanvariance mv. We study the riskaverse newsvendor model with a meanvariance objective function. Lau 33 analyzes the classical newsvendor model under two different objectives namely, maximizing the decisionmakers expected utility of total profit and.
In order to calculate variances, standards and budgetary targets have to be set in advance against which the organizations performance can be compared against. While it is very necessary to maintain the optimum level of inventory, it is not so easy as well. Ever since then, modi cations, extensions and alternatives to mpt have been worked out to simplify and prioritize assumptions of the theory and to address the limitations of the framework. Chen and federgruen 2000 revisita number of basic inventory models using the mean variance approach.
Time inconsistency of optimal policies of distributionally. Eri can be determined by a point estimate from the speci. The values of assets are taken to be random variables with various expected values. Pioneered by nobel laureate harry markowitz in the 1950s, the meanvariance mv formulation is a fundamental theory for risk management in finance. Analysis of variance anova is a statistical method used to test differences between two or more means. As a result, we carry out a meanvariance analysis of the newsvendor problem. The measure of risk by variance would place equal weight on the upside deviations and downside deviations. The methods are particularly suited for discrete response outcomes. Working paper, graduate school of business, columbia university. In particular, with stockout cost, the riskaverse newsvendor does not necessarily order less than the riskneutral newsvendor.
Estimation of the meanvariance portfolio model in the meanvariance framework, the optimal port folio weight vector, x. In forecasting applications, we never observe the whole population. Game theoretic analysis of supply chain based on mean. Coordinating a supply chain with riskaverse agents under. A mean variance analysis is the process of weighing risk variance against expected return.
A supply chain model with asymmetric capacity information. The newsvendor problem is a fundamental building block for. Meanvariance analysis of the newsvendor model with. Inventory model inventory model is a mathematical model that helps business in determining the optimum level of inventories that should be maintained in a production process, managing frequency of ordering, deciding on quantity of goods or raw materials to be stored, tracking flow of supply of raw materials and goods to provide uninterrupted service to customers without any delay in delivery. Risk analysis using the mean variance theory, the last topic, is first incorporated into inventory control problem especially newsvendor problem that is the optimal product order quantity for a. Coordination of a supply chain university of texas at dallas. Chen and federgruen 6 analyze the meanvariance tradeoffs in newsvendor models as well as some standard infinite horizon inventory models. Financial economics i slide 057 asset portfolio a meanvariance dominates asset portfolio b if. The meanvariance analysis was first proposed by markowitz to measure the risk associated with the return of assets.
8 542 999 1070 1034 799 1495 1036 945 1551 551 1465 1486 1307 154 697 807 393 1144 927 260 476 1166 894 849 662 506 887 1139 1140